Law Offices of:

Allen E. Kaye, P.C.

111 Broadway, 13th Floor
New York, NY 10006
Tel: (212) 964-5858
Fax: (212) 608-3734
 


WHAT YOU SHOULD KNOW

As a Lawful Permanent Resident of The United States

I. INTRODUCTION
Congratulations! You have been admitted to the United States as a Lawful Permanent Resident. This change in your status will have a dramatic effect on your legal rights in this country.
As summarized below, permanent residents are entitled to the enjoyment of many new rights and privileges. Likewise, permanent residents are required to comply with several new duties and obligations. The purpose of this pamphlet is to provide you with a summary of these rights and duties in order that you can begin to understand the meaning of your new status as a permanent resident of the United States. But first, a word about your Permanent Resident Card.
This card (formerly Form I-151, now Form I-551, and commonly referred to as a "green card") is evidence of your registration, as required by law, and of your status as a legal permanent resident. It is mailed to you within 2 to 12 months after your admission with an immigrant visa to the United States or, if you are already in the United States, after you adjust to permanent residence status. Any accompanying child, if not a United States citizen, must be presented by a parent or legal guardian at the nearest Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) office for fingerprinting within 30 days of reaching 14 years of age.
Every permanent resident 18 years of age and over must keep the card in his or her personal possession. Use of your card by any other person is unlawful. Immediately notify the nearest INS office if your card is lost or stolen.
Your card contains an eight or nine digit number preceded by the letter A. This is your official file number. Record this number for reference. Whenever communicating with the INS, provide your file number, your full name, the country of your birth and your birth date.
You should keep this pamphlet with your important personal documents for future reference.

-- Allen E. Kaye

II. RIGHTS AND PRIVILEGES ENJOYED BY PERMANENT RESIDENTS

A. THE RIGHT TO BECOME A U.S. CITIZEN

  1. Your Most Significant Right: You are eligible to apply for citizenship once you have been a permanent resident for five years. The application can be filed three months before you are eligible. However, the enjoyment of this right - to apply for naturalization - is not automatic and will be successful only if you comply with several requirements. These are discussed below.
  2. Physical Presence and Residence Requirement: During the five years you have been a permanent resident, you must have been in the United States 50% of the time. Only then can you file an application. If you break your continuous residence by departing for a year or more (even with a Re-Entry Permit), or for six months or more without a good reason, then you must re-establish residence upon your return and wait four years before filing (or two years if you are married to a U.S. citizen).
  3. Qualified Period Shortened for Persons Married to U.S. Citizens: If you are married to a U.S. citizen and you and your spouse have lived together for three years since your spouse became a U.S. citizen, you are eligible to file for naturalization. You too, must have been a permanent resident for three years.
    This special rule applies only if the parties are living together at the time of filing. If a citizen spouse has been assigned abroad by a U.S. corporation developing international trade or by certain governmental, international, or non-profit organizations, then you may be eligible to be naturalized immediately through an expedited procedure before you leave the United States [Immigration & Nationality Act, Section 319(b)].
  4. Preserving Residence: If you leave the United States to work for a U.S. government agency, an international agency, certain religious organizations, or a U.S.-owned firm you may, under certain circumstances, qualify for relief from the continuous residence requirement. If you fail to seek this relief, you may have to wait up to three additional years to qualify for naturalization. You should apply for this relief before you depart the United States. The requirement that you be physically present in the U.S. for 50% of the five- or three-year qualifying period still remains.
  5. Personal Interview and Examination: The application process may take up to two years, depending on where you live at the time of application. An interview will be scheduled during which you will be tested about American government and history as well as your ability to read and write in English. Long time elderly residents and those with impairments may qualify for exemption from the English language requirements. In addition, the INS may choose to review your original basis for becoming a permanent resident. INS officials may want to know whether you remained with your spouse or the employer who petitioned for you for a "reasonable" period of time. There is no single definition of what is "reasonable" - it all depends on the facts and circumstances of each individual case. In addition to meeting the above requirements, you will have to show that you are a person of good moral character. Because the naturalization examiner may challenge your original basis for becoming a permanent resident, it is a good idea to have an experienced immigration lawyer with you when you are examined.
  6. Dual Citizenship: The law of your country may allow you to retain your native citizenship after you become a U.S. citizen. You should contact your country's Embassy or Consulate to check with them.
  7. Benefits of Naturalization: Becoming a permanent resident puts you on the path to becoming a naturalized citizen of the United States. Citizenship carries extensive additional benefits: the right to vote and to hold office, immunity from immigration laws and deportation, the right to a U.S. passport, opportunities for security clearance and special jobs, protection from certain estate taxes, and the right to certain income tax advantages.

B. THE RIGHT TO TRAVEL ABROAD

  1. Receiving Your Resident Alien Card: As stated previously, your green card should arrive in the mail two to twelve months after the approval of your permanent resident status. Meanwhile, you may travel abroad provided the INS has stamped your passport with temporary evidence of your permanent resident status and provided you return to the United States before the expiration date of that stamp. The Postal Service is instructed not to forward Form I-551. The card has an expiration date ten years from the approval date. If you do not become a citizen by then, you will remain a permanent resident, but you must obtain a new card for foreign travel or employment purposes. If the card has an expiration date two years from issuance, you are classified as a "conditional resident" and you are required to file a petition prior to the expiration date in order to preserve your permanent resident status. See Section III(D) below for more details.
  2. Green Card as a Travel Document: A permanent resident uses the Permanent Resident Card in lieu of a visa to return to the United States after a trip abroad of less than one year. Note, however, that if something happens while you are outside the United States that affects your right to return, such as conviction of a crime, contracting a disease or mental illness, you could have difficulty re-entering the United States. If you travel and remain abroad more than twelve months, you risk exclusion unless you have a valid Re-Entry Permit, a document different from your Permanent Resident Card.
  3. Re-Entry Permits: You must apply for a Re-Entry Permit. The Permit will allow you to remain outside the United States for up to two years. The application for a Re-Entry Permit must be filed and received by INS before you leave the U.S., but processing by INS may be completed while you are abroad. A Re-Entry Permit cannot be extended, but a new Permit may be requested for an additional two-year period. You will have to return to the U.S. to make the new application. You should obtain legal advice before you depart the U.S. for any prolonged period or for any period that will involve employment abroad.
  4. If You Work Outside the United States: Consult with us to be sure you have done everything possible to declare your intention to return to your residence here. Apply for a Re-Entry Permit if there is any possibility that you will remain outside the United States for a year or more; file an Application to Preserve Your Residence for Naturalization Purposes if you have a United States employer or work for a qualifying international or religious organization; file resident U.S. tax returns for your earnings both inside and outside the U.S.; consult a tax advisor knowledgeable in taxation while working abroad (we will be happy to make a referral); and consider whether you may be eligible for expedited naturalization [See II(A)(3) above].

C. THE RIGHT TO FILE A PETITION FOR RELATIVES

  1. The Petition: One of the most important benefits you have as a permanent resident is the right to petition for certain relatives. A successful petition entitles the relative to enter the United States as a permanent resident, the same legal status as you currently enjoy.
  2. Eligibility: Under current law, eligible relatives include only your spouse and unmarried children of any age. No other relative is eligible. When you become a citizen, you will be entitled to petition for your parents, married children, and brothers and sisters.
  3. Filing: You may file a petition for an eligible relative once you have been granted permanent residence even though your Form I-551 green card has not arrived. Since the waiting period for a visa for relatives may be several years, it is essential that you file a petition as soon as possible.
  4. Seeking Legal Advice: Sometimes it is preferable to allow your relative to apply for residence based on employment rather than on personal relationship. Sometimes it is best to have your relative apply for a temporary visa before filing a relative petition. The U.S. immigration laws can be very complex. They involve more than simply filling out forms. I recommend that you seek legal advice before filing a petition, in order to efficiently plan for the future. Please call us for assistance.

D. THE RIGHT TO REMAIN IN THE UNITED STATES PERMANENTLY
Another major benefit you now enjoy as a Permanent Resident is the ability to remain in the United States indefinitely, assuming that you obey U.S. laws.

E. THE RIGHT TO LOCAL GOVERNMENT BENEFITS

  1. Entitlement Benefits: In the United States, many public benefits are administered and distributed by local and state governments. Typical benefits include public assistance and the right to obtain certain types of business and recreational licenses. The number and extent of such benefits varies from state to state and from municipality to municipality.
  2. Only Permanent Residents Eligible: States and municipalities award most benefits only to citizens and permanent residents.

F. THE RIGHT TO PUBLIC EDUCATION BENEFITS

  1. Equal Treatment of Permanent Residents: As a permanent resident, you are entitled to the same benefits as U.S. citizens. States are required to treat permanent residents in the same way as U.S. citizens for these purposes.
  2. In-State Tuition: Most states allow permanent residents to pay in-state tuition rates if they meet the state's criteria for such designation. In-state tuition can save a student's family several thousands of dollars annually.

G. THE RIGHT TO PROTECTION AGAINST REMOVAL (DEPORTATION)
Permanent residents have more alternatives than do other aliens when it comes to relief from removal (deportation). For example, aliens who have held permanent resident status for five years and have actually resided continuously in the U.S. for seven years, may be eligible to apply for relief from removal (deportation) under Section 240A of the Immigration and Nationality Act. Eligibility to apply is most beneficial since it allows the permanent resident to present his or her equities to an Immigration Judge who has the discretionary power to rule that the permanent resident should not be removed (deported).

H. THE RIGHT TO PRIVATE-SECTOR BENEFITS
Some employers and private-sector institutions give preferential treatment to permanent residents over other aliens by requiring as a condition of employment that employees be either citizens or permanent residents. Employers may also lawfully discriminate against non-permanent residents. For example, some employers may require new employees to undergo a background check and/or a security clearance as a condition of employment.

I. THE RIGHT TO SOCIAL SECURITY BENEFITS

  1. Application: You may obtain a Social Security Card as soon as you have INS employment authorization, Form I-551, or the temporary I-551 stamp in your passport. You must file an application in person at your local Social Security office. You should bring the following documents with you: passport and proof of permanent resident status. For more information call (800) 772-1212.
  2. Restrictions: If you already have your Social Security Card, but it is not valid for employment, or is not valid without an INS employment authorization document, you should contact your local Social Security office and present evidence of your Permanent Resident status. The restriction will be removed.
  3. Social Security Account: Even if you have a Social Security number, you should check to insure that you received credit according to Social Security regulations for any taxable work you did before becoming a permanent resident. Sometimes Social Security officials misplace records if you did not have a valid card. This is the time to check. Ask your local Social Security Office for Form SSA-7004 (Request for Earnings and Benefit Estimate Statement) to check these records. In fact, you should check your earnings statement every three to four years because errors more than four years old usually cannot be corrected.
  4. Misusing a Social Security Number: You should be aware that it is a serious criminal offense to use someone else's Social Security number or to use a falsely obtained one. If you have done so, seek legal advice before contacting a Social Security office.
  5. Totalization Treaties: If you were assigned by your employer abroad to work in the United States, it may be possible to claim an exemption from U.S. Social Security taxes and to claim a refund for Social Security taxes paid by your employer in the past three tax years. To do this, your employer must have paid into your home country's Social Security system. This provision of law can result in a substantial refund without a sacrifice of benefits, if the Social Security tax rate is lower overseas. Most European countries have a totalization treaty in force with the United States. These include: Austria, Belgium, Canada, Finland, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Norway, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland and the United Kingdom. Since it may be possible to claim coverage under your home country's Social Security system even after you become a permanent resident of the United States, you should consider this option carefully.
  6. Collecting Benefits: You should note that if you are out of the U.S. for six months or more you cannot collect social security benefits overseas.

III. DUTIES, OBLIGATIONS, AND RESTRICTIONS FACING
A PERMANENT RESIDENT

A. TAXATION

  1. U.S. Resident Tax Return: As a permanent resident, you must pay U.S. income taxes on your total worldwide income. If you were previously in the United States on a temporary work visa, probably only your U.S. income was subject to U.S. taxation. You should begin to pay taxes as a U.S. resident, filing a return no later than April 15 of the year after you become a permanent resident. Failure to do so could result in civil or even criminal penalties. You will also be required to pay state income taxes if you live in a state that requires it. The only basis for not filing taxes is if your income is insufficient to require filing. It is best to consult an accountant if you have taxation questions. Call us if you would like a referral.
  2. Witholding Taxes: Your employer is required to withhold a portion of your salary for the payment of taxes on your wages. If you are self-employed, you will have to pay your own Social Security taxes when you file your annual income tax return.

B. MILITARY DUTY

  1. Registration: Men age 18 to 26 are required to register for Selective Service within thirty days of their eighteenth birthday. This requirement applies to permanent residents, citizens, and any other persons in the United States who are not in lawful nonimmigrant status. Failure to register is a felony with a potential penalty of up to five years imprisonment and a fine of up to $250,000. Responsibility to register ends on the twenty-sixth birthday. If you become a permanent resident before your twenty-sixth birthday, it may be in your best interest to register for Selective Service (otherwise you may disqualify yourself from citizenship). Depending on your country of citizenship, you may be exempt from military service. However, because claiming such exemption may disqualify you from citizenship, you should consider this matter very carefully and consider seeking legal advice.
  2. Purpose of Registration: Selective Service Registration does not mean that you will have to enter the Armed Forces. Registration is only so that the Armed Forces may call upon you in the event of a national emergency.
  3. Registration May Be a Prerequisite: Selective Service Registration may be a prerequisite to obtain certain benefits, including naturalization and other benefits such as student financial aid and federal employment. For more information, you may call Selective Service toll-free at (800) 621-5388.

C. CHANGE OF ADDRESS

  1. Notification Required: If you move, you are required to report your new address to the INS District Office within ten days of your move. Failure to report your address may be a ground for removal (deportation). Also, if you move out of state, you may incur significant delays when you file for naturalization. We will be happy to notify INS for you if you keep us informed of any future changes of address.
  2. Annual Update Not Necessary: It is not necessary to register your current address annually with the INS.

D. CONDITIONAL RESIDENCE

  1. Who Is a Conditional Resident: An alien who qualifies for permanent residence (a) on the basis of a marriage to a U.S. citizen or permanent resident that took place less than two years earlier, or (b) as an employment creation immigrant because of an entrepreneurial investment receives a green card valid for two years only. This is called Conditional Residence. Conditional Residents must take further steps to become full-fledged permanent residents.
  2. What Action Must Be Taken:
         a) If you qualified on the basis of a marriage to a U.S. citizen or permanent resident, you and your spouse must file a joint petition during the 90-day period before the second anniversary of your approval for permanent residence (before the expiration date of your green card, Form I-551). You must file the petition only during that 90-day period. You will be subject to removal (deportation) if you fail to file this petition on time. You will be required to document your on-going marital relationship or, if no longer married, that your marriage was valid at its inception and that you are otherwise eligible for a waiver. Extensive documentation is required and your spouse will have to sign the petition unless you seek a waiver of the requirement that you and your spouse file a joint petition. An immigration lawyer can be very helpful if you cannot file the joint petition and must apply for a waiver.
       b) If you are qualified as an employment creation immigrant because of an entrepreneurial investment, you will be required to file a petition during the 90-day period before the second anniversary of your approval for permanent residence (before the expiration date of your green card, Form I-551). You must file the petition only during that 90-day period. You will become deportable if you fail to file this petition on time. You will be required to document that you completed the investment on which your approval for permanent residence was based, that the business continues to operate, and that the required ten jobs for American workers either have been, or soon will be, created. Extensive documentation is required. An immigration lawyer can be very helpful in preparing the necessary petition.
  3. Documentation:
          a) Conditional residents who qualified on the basis of marriage should start preparing documentation of the continuing marital relationship during the two years before the condition is to be removed. These include: records of jointly held property and bank accounts, insurance covering your spouse and naming your spouse as beneficiary, bills and correspondence addressed to you at the same address, photographs of the two of you together, leases or deeds naming both, etc. Save these documents for the time when you consult us about filing the required petition. (Even if the conditional residence status is removed and you receive a green card valid for ten years, we suggest that you may want to save these documents for three years, to demonstrate that your permanent residence was based on a marriage to a U.S. citizen. You will need such documentation when you apply for naturalization.)
          b) Conditional residents who qualified as employment creation immigrants should be sure to maintain detailed business records, including copies of tax filings and payments, employment records, records of transactions, and any other evidence that the business is in operation. Have these documents ready when you consult us about filing the required petition. Also, consult us at any time during the two-year period if you are considering closing or selling the business.
  4. Interview: Conditional residents may be required to appear for an interview after the petition is filed. If your case is carefully documented, the interview may be waived. If you are no longer living with the spouse who petitioned for you, the interview can be quite extensive and the INS may reconsider the basis for your permanent resident status. We suggest that you contact us whether or not you are living with your spouse, in order to avoid any problems.
  5. Seek Our Assistance: Contact us 18-20 months after you obtain your conditional residence status. At that time, we will discuss current procedures and techniques.

E. LOSS OF PERMANENT RESIDENT STATUS

  1. Possibility of Losing Status: Although you are a permanent resident, you remain an alien. Therefore, it is still possible for you to lose your permanent resident status if you depart the United States and are later found to have abandoned your residence.
  2. Abandonment of Status: Loss of permanent resident status could occur if you accept a permanent job abroad, if you fail to file a U.S. resident tax return, if you stay outside the United States for more than one year without a valid Re-Entry Permit, or if you are otherwise found to have abandoned your residence in the United States. In determining whether you have abandoned your American residence, the INS will consider a number of factors (no one factor will be decisive) such as: evidence of intent to reside in the United States; maintaining assets in the United States such as real estate, savings accounts or other investments; the presence of family in the United States; and the payment of U.S. taxes and the retention of property and contacts in the U.S. (such as membership in associations, religious affiliations, credit or brokerage accounts). You do not necessarily have to own or rent a home here, but that is always a helpful factor. On the other hand, if you do not spend significant time in the United States or have not established a "home" here, or if you enter the U.S. with a wallet or purse full of foreign documents (driver's license, credit cards, etc.), or refer to your residence overseas as "home", that may call attention to the possibility that you have abandoned your U.S. residence.
  3. Criminal Convictions: You may also lose your status if you are convicted of a crime involving moral turpitude or other serious offenses. Minor drug offenses may result in loss of permanent resident status as well. You should consult us if you are arrested for any reason at all.
  4. Lack of Eligibility for Permanent Residence: You may also lose your status if it is determined that you were ineligible for permanent resident status at the time you received it. This can happen if you worked or remained in the United States without INS authorization prior to adjusting your status or were otherwise excludable or deportable.
  5. Effect of Divorce: You may also be found ineligible for permanent resident status if you separated from the spouse or employer who petitioned for you shortly after obtaining status. You should consult with us before taking such action. These matters must be taken seriously. Even a person who has lived in the United States as a permanent resident since early childhood may lose his or her status and face deportation proceedings.
  6. Benefits of Citizenship: When a permanent resident becomes a naturalized citizen, U.S. immigration laws no longer affect his or her stay in the U.S.

IV. MAINTAINING CONTACT WITH OUR OFFICE

It has been our pleasure to have assisted you in reaching your goal of becoming a Permanent Resident of the United States. If you keep us advised of your address, we will attempt to notify you of critical matters, such as eligibility for naturalization and other happenings that may affect your status. Should you need the help of an attorney in the future, we hope you will contact us. We would appreciate your providing our name to your friends or relatives who may need an attorney. Thank you for the opportunity to have been of service to you.

Allen E. Kaye is an attorney with law offices at
111 Broadway, 13th Floor,
New York, New York 10006.
Tel.: 212/964-5858. Fax: 212/608-3734.
E-mail: AllenEKaye@Compuserve.com.
Website: www.kayevisalaw.com.

He has concentrated in the practice of U.S. Immigration Law for 30 years. Mr. Kaye is a past national President of the American Immigration Lawyers Association (AILA).

All rights reserved. No part of this pamphlet may be reproduced or copied by any means without the express written permission of the author.

© Copyright January 15, 2003 by Allen E. Kaye.

 







About Us | What's New | General Information | Publications
Resources | Testimonials | Contact Us | Home

Email: allenekaye@compuserve.com

Copyright © 2008 Allen E. Kaye, P.C. --- Site created by Intelligent Graphix